ENTRY 0501 · Spring openers · Benton
Big Singing Day and the shape-note songs
On a Sunday in late May, singers gather in Benton to sing from the Southern Harmony, a tunebook from 1835, in a tradition the town has kept since the 1880s.
Most of the year, Benton is a quiet county seat a short drive from Kentucky Lake. On one Sunday in late May, it becomes the home of one of the oldest surviving traditions of American hymn singing. Singers come from Marshall County and from much farther afield to take part in Big Singing Day, a gathering built around the Southern Harmony tunebook.
The Big Singing has been held in Benton since 1884, which makes it one of the longest-running events of its kind in the country. It has outlasted the singing schools and church traditions that once kept shape-note music common across the rural South.
A tunebook from 1835
The Southern Harmony was compiled by William Walker of South Carolina and first published in 1835. It was one of several tunebooks of the period that used shape notes, a system meant to help ordinary people learn to read music. The book gathered hymns, folk tunes, fuguing tunes and anthems, and it sold widely in the South for decades.
Later tunebooks, especially the Sacred Harp, became more widely used, and the Southern Harmony fell out of common use in most places. Benton is one of the few places where the old book is still sung at a public gathering year after year, which gives the event a special place among people who love this music.
How shape notes work
In shape-note music, each note head has a shape that tells the singer which syllable to sing. The Southern Harmony uses four shapes: a triangle for fa, an oval for sol, a rectangle for la and a diamond for mi. The syllables repeat up the scale, and once a singer knows the shapes, a new tune becomes easier to read.
Singers usually sing through a song first using the syllables, then sing the words. The effect of the syllables alone can be startling for a first-time listener: a dense, ringing sound with no words at all, followed by the hymn text in full voice.
The music itself is unlike most church singing heard today. The melody often lies in the tenor part, not the top line, and the harmonies are open and sometimes rough, with bare fifths and parallel motion that a trained choir would avoid. Singers do not aim for polish. They aim for full voices and steady time, and the sound fills a room in a way that is hard to describe until you hear it.
ALSO ENTERED · APRILTater Day in Benton
The tunes come from many sources. Some are old folk melodies from the British Isles set to hymn texts; others were written by American composers of the singing-school era. A fuguing tune starts with all parts together, then breaks into staggered entries that chase one another before coming back together. The effect is lively and a little wild, and it is one of the reasons people come back.
The singing in Benton
The singing traditionally takes place in Benton on the fourth Sunday in May. The location has been at or near the county courthouse over the years; check the current announcement for the venue and start time, as arrangements can change.
Singers sit in a square, grouped by part, facing one another. A leader stands in the centre, calls a song by its page number, and keeps time with a hand. Leaders take turns through the day. A midday meal has long been part of the gathering, in the tradition of dinner on the grounds that once went with many rural singings and church homecomings.
The day moves at its own pace. Songs follow one another with little ceremony, and the hours pass in a rhythm of singing, short pauses and the next page number called out. Many of the songs are about faith, death, heaven and hope, and the words carry real weight for many in the room.
Listening with respect
Visitors are generally welcome to listen, and some singings invite newcomers to sit in and try. Still, it is worth remembering that this is a religious gathering for many people and a family tradition for others. A few simple courtesies help:
- Arrive before the singing begins, and come and go quietly between songs.
- Sit at the edges of the room unless you are invited into the square.
- Silence your phone and avoid talking during the singing.
- Ask before recording or photographing, and never use a flash.
- If you would like to sing, ask one of the regular singers how best to join.
Treat it as you would a church service you are visiting for the first time, and you will be welcome.
A weekend in Benton
Benton has another old tradition worth knowing. Tater Day in Benton has marked the start of spring each April since 1843, and the town's two great gatherings make an interesting pair: one a noisy trade day with a parade and a midway, the other a day of old hymns sung in four shapes.
Late May is a fine time to be near the lakes. Kentucky Lake and Lake Barkley are warming up, and Land Between the Lakes is green and full. The elk and bison prairie is a good evening drive after a long day of singing, and the Homeplace 1850s farm shows how rural families in this region lived in the decades when the Southern Harmony was new.
If you have time before or after the singing, walk around downtown Benton and the courthouse square. The town is small and easy to see on foot, and a quiet Sunday afternoon in late May is a pleasant time to do it.
Why the singing lasts
Shape-note singing has drawn new interest in recent decades, with groups forming in cities across the country and abroad. Many of those singers come to know Benton as one of the places where the old practice was never broken. That continuity is what makes the day worth the drive.
The singing in Benton also connects to a wider history of the rural South, when singing schools travelled from community to community to teach young people to read music. The shape-note system was invented to make that teaching quicker, and tunebooks like the Southern Harmony were the textbooks. A day in Benton offers a glimpse of that world.
You do not need to know anything about music to feel the power of a room full of voices singing a tune that has been sung in Benton for well over a century. Come early, sit quietly and let the sound wash over you.
NEXT ON THE CALENDAR · MAY