Marion FairKentucky's fairs and back-road festivals, month by month
May

ENTRY 0502 · Spring openers · Owensboro

Mutton and burgoo in Owensboro

Owensboro barbecues sheep, not pigs, and serves it with a thick stew called burgoo. Here is how the tradition works, from parish picnics to the May riverfront festival.

Ask for barbecue in most of the South and you will get pork. Ask for it in Owensboro and you are likely to get mutton, smoked slowly over hickory coals, chopped or sliced and served with a thin, dark dip. Beside it comes a bowl of burgoo, a thick stew that has been simmering since before dawn. The combination is particular to this stretch of the Ohio River, and Owensboro, the seat of Daviess County, has built a reputation on it.

The town has long called itself a barbecue capital, and each spring it has held a festival on the riverfront to prove it. Even outside festival time, the tradition is easy to find at church picnics and on the menus of local places through the summer.

Why mutton

The mutton tradition goes back to the region's farms. Sheep were once common in this part of Kentucky, raised for wool and meat. An old ewe past her prime made tough eating, but long, slow cooking over coals turned her into something tender and full of flavour. That method suited big community gatherings, where a few sheep could feed a crowd.

Mutton is stronger in flavour than lamb, with a richer, gamier taste. The long smoke softens it, and the dip seasons it. First-timers are sometimes wary, but many come away converts.

Cooking mutton well takes time. Pitmasters build hickory fires and let them burn down to coals, then set the meat on grates above. The heat is low and steady, and the meat cooks for many hours, turned and basted as it goes. Shoulders, ribs and other cuts each have their followers. Chopped mutton is the most common order, but sliced mutton and ribs have their fans, and regulars often have firm opinions on which cut is best.

The dip is part of what makes Owensboro mutton distinct. Often called black dip, it is a thin sauce built on vinegar and Worcestershire sauce with pepper and other seasoning. It is brushed on during cooking and served alongside, and it is quite different from the thick, sweet sauces found elsewhere.

What goes into burgoo

Burgoo is a thick stew that has been part of Kentucky gatherings for generations. It is cooked in big kettles, sometimes over open fires, and stirred with long wooden paddles for hours. Recipes vary from cook to cook and are often guarded, but most share a basic shape.

In Owensboro, mutton is usually among the meats, along with chicken and sometimes beef or pork. Vegetables follow: potatoes, onions, corn, cabbage, tomatoes, lima beans and okra are common. The stew cooks down until the meat falls apart and the vegetables merge into a thick, peppery whole. A good burgoo should be thick enough that a spoon nearly stands up in it.

Burgoo has its own long history in Kentucky, tied to political rallies, church picnics and community feeds. Its origins are disputed, but its role is not: it is a dish made in quantity, for a crowd, by people who cook it once or twice a year with great care.

A good burgoo should be thick enough that a spoon nearly stands up in it.

The church cook teams

Much of Owensboro's barbecue culture runs through its churches. Catholic parishes in Daviess County and the surrounding area have long held summer picnics, and many feature mutton, chicken and burgoo cooked by parish volunteers. The cooks often start the night before, tending pits through the dark hours, and the work passes from one generation to the next.

These picnics are the heart of the tradition. They run through the warmer months, with schedules set by each parish. Dates change from year to year, so watch local announcements for the current schedule. Many sell food by the plate, by the pound or by the gallon, and some take orders for carry-out.

ALSO ENTERED · AUGUST

The Fancy Farm Picnic

Visitors are welcome at most of these picnics, which raise money for the parishes. Bring cash, expect lines at lunchtime, and follow the lead of regulars when it comes to ordering. A nearby tradition with a very different flavour is the Fancy Farm Picnic in Graves County, another church gathering famous for its barbecue, held each August.

The May festival on the river

For many years, Owensboro has held a barbecue festival on its riverfront in May. Church teams have competed to cook mutton, chicken and burgoo, and the riverfront has filled with smoke, music and crowds. The pitmasters' work began long before the gates opened, and the smell drifted across downtown.

The festival's format and schedule have changed over the years, and it does not run every year on the same pattern. Before you plan a trip around it, check the current announcement from the festival organisers or the city to confirm whether it is being held and when. If it is not on in a given year, the parish picnics through the summer offer the same food in a more local setting.

The riverfront itself is worth a visit in any season. Owensboro has rebuilt its waterfront with parks, fountains and walkways along the Ohio River. The blue-painted bridge across the river to Indiana is a local landmark, and the view at sunset over the water is a fine way to end a day of eating.

A parish picnic has the feel of a homecoming. Families come back to the parish where they grew up, older parishioners sit in the shade and catch up, and children run between the tents. Alongside the food there are often games, raffles, music and bingo. Even if you know no one there, the welcome is easy, and buying a plate is the simplest way to take part.

Chicken is the other mainstay. Barbecued chicken, cooked over the same pits as the mutton, gives timid eaters a safe choice and is often just as popular. Sides tend to be simple: slaw, potato salad, bread, pickles and onions. The focus stays on the meat and the stew.

Eating your way through the tradition

If this is your first taste of Owensboro barbecue, a few tips help:

  • Try mutton first, even if you are unsure. It is the point of the trip.
  • Ask for dip on the side so you can judge the meat on its own.
  • Order burgoo by the bowl, and if you like it, buy more to take home.
  • Bring cash for church picnics and small stands.
  • Go early; popular items sell out.

Mutton and burgoo are part of a wider Kentucky world of food tied to gatherings. Barbecue and burgoo turn up at county fairs, and in the hills to the east, autumn brings sorghum stirring-offs and the apple festival in Paintsville. Each tells you something about how rural Kentucky feeds a crowd.

Owensboro beyond the plate

Owensboro is one of Kentucky's larger cities and has more to offer than barbecue. The downtown has museums, a performing arts scene and a strong tie to bluegrass music; the Bluegrass Music Hall of Fame and Museum makes its home here. A walk along the river and through downtown makes a good way to settle a big meal.

The region around the town is farm country, with fields of corn, soybeans and tobacco stretching away from the river. In late summer, the county fairs of western Kentucky bring their own food, barns and grandstand shows.

Mutton and burgoo may not be what you expect from Kentucky barbecue. They are what Owensboro has cooked for generations, and that is reason enough to try them.

NEXT ON THE CALENDAR · JUNE

Farm stands on the Amish back roads